Friday, January 9, 2026

Johann Joseph Ignaz von Döllinger vs. the claim Hegessipus was an Ebionite

  

St. James is thus mentioned by Hegesippus (apud. Euseb. ii.23); " He was holy from his mother's womb; wine and strong drink he did not drink; neither did he eat of flesh; the scissors never touched his head; he anointed not himself with oil ; he frequented not the baths; he wore not woollen, but linen garments." From this passage it has been thought by some writers that Hegesippus was an Ebionite; this cannot have been, for he states that the result of his journeys, undertaken for this express purpose, had been, that he had found an uniformity of faith in all the Churches which he visited, in the east and west. An Ebionite could not have written thus. If, in a fragment preserved by Stephen Gabarus (apud Routh, i. 203), he seems to reject the expression, " that eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, and that it hath not come into the heart of man to conceive, the good things prepared by God for those who love him," by a reference to Matt. xiii. 16, he certainly does not wish to differ from St. Paul, but only to refute a misinterpretation of the Gnostics. This description of the Nazarean life of the apostle, he probably drew from an apocryphal book, cited by St. Epiphanius, entitled, Αναβαθμοι Ίακωβου. (Johann Joseph Ignaz von Döllinger, A History of the Church, 4 vols. (trans. Edward Cox; London: C. Dolman, 1840], 1:117)

 

Blog Archive