Tuesday, February 18, 2025

Mark L. Hitchcock and Jerry M. Hullinger on the Sacrifices of Ezekiel 40-48

  

Fifth, Gentry’s most strenuous argument is that interpreting the animal sacrifices, circumcision, and priesthood literally in these chapters is “redemptively retrogressive.” However, an examination of the text reveals that there will not be a reinstitution of the Law of Moses in the messianic kingdom, but a new system of kingdom law. While there are some similarities with the Mosaic law, the numerous differences reveal that the systems are not the same. The millennial system of sacrifices and priesthood will not be a reinstitution of the Law of Moses that was terminated permanently with the death of the Messiah. The numerous differences between Ezekiel 40-489 and the Mosaic Law prevented the Jewish rabbis from accepting Ezekiel into the Hebrew canon for some time. (Mark L. Hitchcock, “A Defense of the Domitianic Date of the Book of Revelation” [PhD Dissertation; Dallas Theological Seminary, December 2005], 130)

 

 

A HARMONIZATION OF EZEKIEL 40-48 AND HEBREWS 9-10

 

How does the fact of animal sacrifices being offered in a literal temple in the future millennium, as taught in Ezekiel 40-48, harmonize with the clear assertion made by the author of Hebrews regarding the finality of Christ's offering? The key passage in this regard is Hebrews 9:9-14.

 

One of the weaknesses of the Levitical system was that it could not perfect the conscience. While Paul described the conscience as a moral faculty of judgment, the writer to the Hebrews said the conscience reminds the believer of past sins. The writer of Hebrews pointed out that the internal awareness of sin (i.e., the conscience) was never permanently cleansed by animal sacrifices. Thus the old system, because it was primarily ceremonial, could not resolve the problem of a guilty conscience. For this reason the much greater sacrifice of Christ was necessary.

 

Hebrews 9:10 and 13 state that the Levitical offerings were related to "food and drink and various washings, regulations for the body," and the sprinkling of blood so as to sanctify and purify the flesh. Animal sacrifices were efficacious in removing ceremonial uncleanness. While Christ is superior, the fact should not be lost that animal sacrifices did in the earthly sphere cleanse the flesh and remove outward defilement.

 

Σάρξ ("flesh”) and συνείδησις ("conscience") constitute the two sides of human existence for the author of Hebrews. The earthly side of "flesh" could be cleansed by the earthly Levitical system, whereas the "conscience" side of human existence required a superior sacrifice. The blood of bulls and goats purified the flesh (Heb. 9:13) but it could not perfect the conscience since it dealt only with external cleansing (9:9-10).

 

Hebrews reveals that Christ's death met certain objectives and operated in a sphere different from that of the animal sacrifices of the old economy. Hebrews states that animal sacrifices were efficacious in the sphere of ceremonial cleansing. They were not efficacious, however, in the realm of conscience and therefore in the matter of spiritual salvation. Because of this, Christ's offering is superior in that it accomplished something the Levitical offerings never could, namely, soteriological benefits.

 

Only Christ's sacrifice was of the kind that could form the basis for eternal and spiritual salvation. But this in no way refutes the ... efficacy in the Old Testament sacrifices .... Eternal or spiritual salvation was not the issue. Therefore, the animal sacrifices of the Old Testament and the sacrifice of Christ in the New Testament were effective at their own respective and totally different levels. (Richard E Averbeck, "An Exegetical Study of Leviticus 1 4 with a Discussion of the Nature of Old Testament Atonement" (M Div thesis, Grace Theological Seminary, 1977), 68) (Jerry M. Hullinger, “The Problem of Animal Sacrifices in Ezekiel 40-48,” Biblitotheca Sacra 152 [July-September 1995]: )

 

 

To Support this Blog:

 

Patreon

Paypal

Venmo

Amazon Wishlist

Email for Amazon Gift card: ScripturalMormonism@gmail.com

Email for Logos.com Gift Card: IrishLDS87@gmail.com

Blog Archive